My Generation
This is one of those posts. It's ruminated a long time, and it's still not done. Maybe it doesn't even belong on the blog - for starters, it's far too long. I certainly don't want to grow ungrateful for all I've been given, nor do I want to withdraw from my culture. I find myself happily anticipating coming to America this year. But here are some things I'm learning about my life from the East, if you wish to read...
I've always wondered what cultural blindnesses my upbringing has produced. But living this Asian life the past few years is gradually producing a realization I didn’t expect: the differences I feel most have more to do with my generation than my geography. Bits and pieces gleaned from books and my elders’ memories have made me think perhaps my Asian host culture bears more resemblance to my own country a century ago than does my life thus far. In old stories from home, I read about things that only became familiar to me when I came to this small Himalayan town: carrying water and washing clothes by hand (I don't, but my neighbors do), children who can walk for miles and not bat an eye, a culture without breakfast foods, where hospitality is necessity and not entertainment, bathing is a chore and not a luxury, and a the only good trip is one that’s over.
I've always wondered what cultural blindnesses my upbringing has produced. But living this Asian life the past few years is gradually producing a realization I didn’t expect: the differences I feel most have more to do with my generation than my geography. Bits and pieces gleaned from books and my elders’ memories have made me think perhaps my Asian host culture bears more resemblance to my own country a century ago than does my life thus far. In old stories from home, I read about things that only became familiar to me when I came to this small Himalayan town: carrying water and washing clothes by hand (I don't, but my neighbors do), children who can walk for miles and not bat an eye, a culture without breakfast foods, where hospitality is necessity and not entertainment, bathing is a chore and not a luxury, and a the only good trip is one that’s over.
It’s been a rough transition from my modern life to
this old-fangled one, with its very reasonable limitations – e.g., it’s cold in
the winter, crops have seasons, and if you waste the water, it runs out. Writing in Andy Catlett, Wendell Berry considers just such a reverse cultural
transition as it would affect our culture at large: “I see that we could have
continued that thrifty old life fairly comfortably – could even have improved
it. Now we will have to return to it, or
to a life necessarily as careful, and we will do so only uncomfortably and with
much distress.” I have been surprised at
the distress I’ve experienced in adjusting to this life, which is nevertheless
quite livable, and mostly comfortable. Here
are a few of the assumptions I think I inherited from my culture which have
left me somewhat ill-prepared for the world.
- I expect nearly everything to be available
spur-of-the-moment, even if I have
to pay a little more. Lots of things that require "gestation
time" and can't be rushed, I now make myself (e.g. yeast bread, yogurt,
cream cheese), so they require advance planning. Irrationally, I feel
this as a hardship, and it's comforted me somehow to realize that even the
Kroger cream cheese I used to buy had to be cultured and drained - even though, in my experience, it was available instantly
for $1 almost any time of the day or night. Our fruits and vegetable don’t get airplane tickets, which means, among other things, no more
mango-avocado salad – the seasons don’t align. Stores are open from about 10 AM to 6 PM, 5 or
6 days a week. I know my Mom and Grandmama are still surprised at how
late stores stay open in the US, but I always took for granted that I could
shop after the kids went to bed, or buy something early in the morning for a
last-minute company breakfast. Now I have to plan ahead or do without,
and it's been quite an adjustment - though I'm slowly realizing the doing
without is often more peaceful than making everything just so, just because I
can.
- I expect shelter to be climate controlled;
otherwise it's not really shelter. Of course, there are conditions
that actually threaten survival, but they are far outside the 68-75 degrees
Fahrenheit of Western "room temperature." Most of the time,
having a roof, some walls, clothing, and a fire in winter is actually enough to
stave off the threat from sun or cold. For warmth, people here rely on
sun, clothing, and hot drinks. And for cooling,
it's cucumbers, bitter gourd, watermelon (considered to be so powerful a
coolant that you are sure to fall sick from eating it except in the hottest
mid-day), water, and sometimes fans. Of course, people deal with the
effects of weather. Our neighbors are used to not sleeping well during hot
season, chilblains and few baths in winter, damp clothes and mosquitoes in
monsoon. They feel uncomfortable, but not endangered, whereas experiencing
climatic effects at home is such a change from my ingrained cultural patterns
that it can make me feel threatened.
- I expect pain to be an aberration and not an
integral part of work and play. I'm thankful for OSHA and for safety
testing of children's products, but it is easy to see how closely tied the
thinking that produced them is to the sense that if I get hurt, something is
wrong. Besides the actual pain or injury, there is the angst of injustice
to be borne. By contrast, people here don't expect to be spared pain, or
even injury. Recently we learned a game from neighbors (from another
eastern country) where a board is balanced over a brick or rock, and two kids
jump on either end of the board, timing their jumps so that they go higher with
each bounce...until someone falls off, or the board skews sideways sending them
both to the ground. Most of the time they bounce back up laughing, but
not always. It's considered a fun game with acceptable risk. The
playgrounds here are fun, and reckless. The slides are death-defying.
The swings break, the chains are precariously re-attached, and kids swing
until they break again. Kids hurt each other and grown-ups don’t gasp.
Painters and electricians work carefully, with minimal safety equipment.
Survival rather than comfort is the goal of medicine, and if people go to
the doctor, it's because they are willing to get worse to get better. Sometimes I wonder if this is why we tend to
keep the aged or sick secluded in the West - they threaten our conviction that
we can achieve a pain-free existence. I'm often shocked here, and I don't always let
my kids play on the swings, but I do hope they grow up knowing that pain is
part of life and does not always require redress.
- I expect to show and receive regard by the
valuing of individuals' time. In the US, I can show care by
letting someone go ahead of me at the restaurant door or in the intersection.
That doesn't make sense in a collective culture like this one; the goal
is to get everyone through the door, or down the street. Lines don't form, because equality is not a
matter of valuing everyone's time the same. There is no concept of owning
time; even linguistically, time "passes," it isn't "spent."
People value each other in lots of ways - greetings, visits, hospitality,
cooperation, gifts, asking help or advice - but not in respecting each other's
time. Visiting someone shows them honor, and it's usually viewed as
giving, not taking; hence people don't ask permission. There is quite literally
no concept of hearing the knock at the door and not answering; either need or
visitor must be met. In a cooperative society, being available may be a
matter of life or death. People have a right to each other's time.
- I expect society to be
arranged in such a way that the individual, not the extended family unit, can
be self-sufficient. Thus our society values handicapped access and
childcare for workers, but on the darker side we abort children whom we fear
will not be self-sufficient, and release foster children to the streets at 18. A successful individual must by definition be independent. One of the primary
fears of our culture is being "dependent,” which sounds irrational indeed
from those who neither grow their own food nor control their own water
supply. Past generations, by contrast,
recognized appropriate and inappropriate dependencies – e.g. borrowing money
from family and not from strangers in time of need. This same scruple (appropriate dependency) was explained to us as a cultural expectation when we arrived in our Asian city. Here, families are expected to have diverse
members with diverse contributions, and to depend on one another. There need to be able-bodied members, of
course, but members who aren't still hold a valued place. Someone is
generally always home, so caring for children or the sick does not disrupt the
household greatly. Without
refrigeration, shopping (or harvesting) and cooking are daily tasks for which
wage earners depend on other family members.
Isolated individuals are usually drawn into a family group on some
terms, though it may not always be as a full member. From here, our individual independence begins
to look like a delicate and carefully-guarded construct.
- I expect to protect, never
expend, my health. One
of the most surprising statements I heard during our preparation for moving
overseas was a comment by a middle-aged wife and mother who had trouble
convincing her doctor in America that she had never smoked, but had instead lived most of
her adult life in an Asian capital. I was taken aback. I thought I was
prepared to sacrifice a lot to be here, but knowingly expending my health day
by day was not on the list. People I meet here are generally protective
of their health not for it's own sake, but in order to judiciously expend it -
for jobs and livelihood, childbearing, travel, surviving illness, and sometimes
political gain (via the oft-used "fast until death" that usually
finds a reason to conclude after a few days), to name a few. In general, the goal
seems to be to survive until their work is done, and the mantle passed to the
next generation. Despite the plentiful veggies, I think that living in
Asia is probably not helpful to our family's long-term health, but
I have come to be at peace with that. Of
course, health often means years of life, but we are fast learning in the West
that the years we buy may not be happy or productive ones. I still value my health; I just hope that I
won't be found to have conserved it against the needs and opportunities of the
days I am living.
- I expect technology, not prudence, to correct for
my excesses. I keep coming back to this example: all my life it
has bothered me that the clean, potable water in the sink never ran out. It simply defies logic. My mother remembered another time, and she taught
me that I should never waste it. I
tried. But I always felt I needed
something more tangible than an “ought,” and my culture had nothing to give.
Since my earliest memories, we’ve excelled like a soap opera at averting
disaster and avoiding all substantial changes to our situation. In elementary school, I learned that several major
metropolitan areas would run out of water in the 1980s. I’ve been told that honey bees were going extinct,
that gasoline prices would make private vehicles a thing of the past, that
overpopulation would wreak havoc on our culture and health. Each time, technology has rescued us. This is why, I think, we continue to live in excess,
in direct contrast to reason and prudence:
our logic is contradicted by our short, western experience of the
world. Our lightweight culture built on
preferences and personnas simply cannot offer us another viable path, or a
reason to change.
But change we will have to. I now
think that those of us who came of age in America in recent decades have lived
in unprecedented comfort, and our home culture is, in many ways, neither
rational nor sustainable. It is somehow
hollow, an emerging culture piggy-backed on an older, more substantial one,
without which we cannot hope to make sense of the world. Berry laments this “new world of cheap energy
and even cheaper money, honored greed, and dreams of liberation from every
restraint,” which he sees as “mostly theater…a jumble of scenery and props
never quite believable, an economy of fantasies and moods.” Now that I live in a world where calories are
friends, rain is welcomed, and guests are a blessing, I can’t shake the feeling
that my generation has grown up in Berry’s theater, thinking it is real. The storybooks tell us that it is always a
difficult process to become “real,” but we are a generation that must be reborn
if we are to survive.
Glad you put this to words. These thoughts are like seeds in monsoon soil that continue to yield for months. I hope to think back on it. They are also the table of contents for the missing orientation manual!
ReplyDeletegood old B, to find Wendall Barry in Asia!! I couldn't agree with you more... though... several of the longest-lived societies in the world hail from such cultures! We definitely will have no shortage of fascinating conversation topics WHEN (hehe not if) you come through!! ;)
ReplyDeleteBethany, thanks so much for sharing this! It is true, poignant, and extremely well put - a great corrective to my own western mentalities. I am so encouraged by y'all's faithfulness.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your encouragement, friends. These ideas are still forming, and I need help knowing what to do with them...besides write that orientation manual - ha! Good conversations due for sure, Christina. :) And I have Laura Dawkins to thank for loaning me Andy Catlett.
ReplyDeletehehe I meant that you "found" him-- as in met his ideas applied around you... not sure if that makes any sense but I'm not sure how to explain it. Basically like I find LoTR/Tolkien, Lewis and HP similarities often.
ReplyDeletei have been waiting til i had long minutes to read this and think with you. thank you so much for sharing the thoughts. i've been intending to write you a "real" letter all week:) laura
ReplyDeleteWow, thank you Bethany. I too am encouraged by ya'lls faithfulness!
ReplyDelete